McCullough chose "Tim McGraw" from Swift's debut album. He confessed he was surprised by how many Swift songs he knew and joked that maybe he is a Swiftie.
By episode's end McCullough advanced to the Top 5 alongside Keyla Richardson, Braden Rumfelt, Hannah Harper and Chris Tungseth; Brooks Rosser and Daniel Stallworth were eliminated. Richie urged eliminated singers to enjoy the moment, find a manager and chase a hit record, warning that once you have a hit "they're going to ask for the next one," and quipping, "I'm 97 years int his business and I'm still not comfortable." American Idol airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.